Fate Can Toss a Boomerang by Carolyn Summer Quinn is a gripping, small-town crime tale that blends the relentless logic of a police investigation with the messy, unforgettable tangle of personal history.
Table of Contents
Review
Boomerang justice delivered.
In forensic psychology, there’s a well-documented phenomenon known as the “recall under pressure” effect—when a familiar trigger, like a street name or a scent, can unlock years-old memories with startling clarity. It’s the same process that can unnerve even the most seasoned investigators, because some cases don’t just test professional skill; they prod at scars. In this story, a December night in Beaumont, Wyoming, pulls Detective Knox Wanamaker out into the wind, to an address he knows for all the wrong reasons. What he finds inside is more than a crime scene; it’s the end of a long, crooked arc that began in a middle-school gym, under the climbing ropes, when he was just a boy who knew enough to push back.
The case, on paper, is deceptively straightforward: a body, a bamboo-handled knife, and a yellow scrap of paper with a strange declaration—“FATE CAN TOSS A BOOMERANG!”—tucked under a wine glass. But the investigation is laced with local politics, a spouse whose grief swings from operatic to oddly flat, and an entire community whose memory of the victim seems painted in conflicting colors. As Knox and his sharp-eyed new partner, Marigold Rivas, sift through evidence and dodge uncooperative witnesses, the real challenge becomes separating fact from long-buried grudges.
The book thrives on its layered premise, walking the line between the satisfaction of solving a puzzle and the unease of realizing that some truths don’t make for tidy endings. The pacing moves like a Wyoming wind—gusting forward in procedural bursts, then slowing to let past and present collide in flashbacks that feel earned rather than forced. The narrator’s voice is distinctive: dry in humor, rich in detail, and capable of turning a scene description—like porcelain clowns leering from a cabinet—into a character moment in itself. The audience it’s written for will find themselves both entertained and engaged, because the balance of police work, small-town character study, and moral complexity is just right for readers who like their mysteries with substance. Its market potential lies in that blend, with enough twists to hook series fans and enough human depth to win over general fiction readers.
Readers who prefer their mysteries free of moral ambiguity, or who shy away from even implied backstories involving wrongdoing in positions of trust, may find the undercurrents unsettling. But for those who appreciate the grit of Louise Penny’s village intrigues or the slow-burn revelations of Tana French’s detectives, this will feel like familiar ground with a fresh layer of frost.
What makes this book stand out is how it dares to let its title resonate through every layer of the plot. A boomerang, after all, doesn’t just fly—it returns. In Quinn’s capable hands, that return is not a neat arc in the sky, but a sharp, wind-whipped curve through the lives of people who thought they’d left certain days behind. The novel contributes to the genre by showing that the best mysteries are not just about catching someone, but about what comes back to strike when fate, memory, and conscience align. Like the gusts that usher Knox to that familiar address, the story stays with you, a reminder that some circles are meant to close.
About the Author
Multi-award-winning author Carolyn Summer Quinn, raised in Roselle and Scotch Plains, NJ, comes from a large extended family. She has lived in New York City for almost forty years and has authored twenty books.
Book Details
- Title: Fate Can Toss a Boomerang: A Murder Mystery
- Author: Carolyn Summer Quinn
- Genre(s): Fiction
- Sub-genre(s): Mystery / Thriller, Police Procedural
- Theme(s): Justice, Revenge, Crime, Memory, Secrets
- Minimum Audience Age: 16+ (due to mature subject matter and crime details)
- Main Language: English
Book Themes
(Note: 0=none, 1=a few, 2=considerable, 3=pronounced, 4=excessive)
- Sexual themes — 3 (pronounced)
- Repeated references to predatory behavior toward minors.
- Religious themes — 0 (none)
- No religious references or themes present.
- Violence, self-harm, etc. — 3 (pronounced)
- Murder scene described with weapon and injury detail.
- Crude language, expletives, swearing, etc. — 3 (pronounced)
- Frequent coarse language and slang profanity.
- Other adult themes — 2 (considerable)
- Includes manipulation, trauma, and moral ambiguity.
Related
Book Review: Not A Shovel In Sight by Carolyn Summer Quinn
What if your old summer job held the key to solving a million-dollar crime? In Not a Shovel in Sight, one woman dives back into her past to unravel a dangerous mystery — but who can she really trust?
Book Review: Child of Secrets From Afar by Carolyn Summer Quinn
What would you do if a secret from your past threatened the safety of someone you love? Check out Child of Secrets From Afar to uncover the heart-pounding answer.
January 2025 BREW Readers’ Choice Awardee: The Mystery from Way Back When by Carolyn Summer Quinn
The Chrysalis BREW Project has named The Mystery from Way Back When by Carolyn Summer Quinn as the January 2025 BREW Readers’ Choice Awardee.
Book Review: Vanished on the Vaudeville Circuit by Carolyn Summer Quinn
What would you do if your life depended on spotting someone in a crowded theater but you weren’t sure they were real? Discover the gripping story in this book.
Book Review: The Mystery from Way Back When by Carolyn Summer Quinn
What do show tunes, an abandoned baby, and a bustling New York life have in common? Discover how Carolyn Summer Quinn’s rollicking journey weaves these threads into her award-winning storytelling.
Editorial Review: “Until the Stars Align” by Carolyn Summer Quinn
Until the Stars Align is a historical fiction by Carolyn Summer Quinn that focuses on the relocation of Jewish children from Germany to Great Britain before the beginning of World War II.
Disclaimer: The content provided by The Chrysalis BREW Project is for informational purposes only. The views expressed in our reviews and articles are those of the individual writers and do not necessarily reflect the official stance of The Chrysalis BREW Project. We strive for accuracy, but we cannot guarantee the completeness or reliability of the information provided. External links are for convenience and do not imply endorsement. Readers are encouraged to conduct their own research and consult professionals as needed. The use of our content is at your own discretion. Please read our full disclaimer version as well as other relevant policies, terms, and conditions on the links below for more details.
Important Reads: About Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Disclaimer and Disclosure
For more posts like this, here’s the link: https://thechrysalisbrewproject.com/category/bookish-posts/.
- A Calendar of BREW Events
- Book Reviews and Recommendations
- BREW Book, Blog, and Poetry Awards
- BREW Book Awards
- BREW International Blog Award
- BREW Poetry Award
- General Award Nomination Policies
- BREW Award Winners
- Become a BREW Awards Judge
- BREW Book Awards Judging Criteria
- BREW Brilliance: Insights and Updates from BREW Awardees
- Policy for Self-reporting, Reporting on Awardees, and Minimum Nominee Criteria
- From the BREW Community
- Get Featured: Showcase Your Work Through The Chrysalis BREW Project
- Giving Back
- Our Free Services for You
- What You Can Also Do
- Partner With Us
- Our Offers
- About
Announcements
Welcome to The Chrysalis BREW Project! We’re excited to offer new service slots to shine a spotlight on your masterpiece—place your order while spots last! If you have any questions, feel free to reach out through our Contact Form and we’ll get back to you as soon as we can. All the best, now and always—keep shining!
Congratulations to our latest BREW award winners!
Something went wrong. Please refresh the page and/or try again.
Share this:
Discover more from The Chrysalis BREW Project
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.