Review of Yesterday Was Not So Long Ago by Ruth Benario (with Peter Benario and Carolyn Zalesne)
Book Review / by The Contributing Writer / 432 views
Title: Yesterday Was Not So Long Ago
Author: Ruth Benario (with Peter Benario and Carolyn Zalesne)
Genre: Memoir / Historical Nonfiction
Sub-genres: WWII Memoir, Coming-of-Age, Cultural History
Themes: Resilience, Moral Complexity, Identity, Family, War, Memory, Cultural Legacy, Love Across Borders
⭐ Review
“What If the Truth Was Quiet?”
Every so often, a memoir whispers the truth so gently that it reaches your soul louder than any shout ever could. Yesterday Was Not So Long Ago is that kind of book.
It doesn’t roar like a battlefield memoir or entangle readers in policy debates. Instead, it lets history walk beside you — in a school hallway, through a city square, along a gravel road lined with church bells, and into the diary of a young German girl, Ruth Pein, who didn’t choose her place in history but learned to navigate it with eyes wide open.
A Story Told with the Luxury of Time and the Burden of Memory
Ruth Benario was born in 1923 in Erfurt, Germany. What makes her story extraordinary is that it dares to explore a widely misunderstood question: what was it like to be a non-Jewish German girl growing up under the Third Reich?
With the benefit of both memory and diary pages she carried across continents, Ruth’s writing — polished later by her son Peter — captures the moment-to-moment confusion of a teenager trying to distinguish loyalty from indoctrination, and love from survival.
She describes family, architecture, holidays, music, boys, war, fear, displacement, and rebirth in ways that make her life tangible, not abstract. Readers don’t just learn about WWII — they feel it, through warm rooms, cold winters, plum thefts, school struggles, and complicated choices.
Science of Memory, Art of Nuance
Neuroscience tells us that emotionally intense memories are preserved more deeply and last longer. Ruth’s vivid recollections — some 80 years after the events — illustrate this phenomenon. But what sets her apart is her refusal to rewrite history in hindsight.
She neither excuses nor indicts blindly. She does not present herself as a hero, nor her homeland as purely villainous. Instead, she does something far more difficult: she tells the truth as it felt when she lived it, without the armor of modern judgment.
A WWII Story Without Guns or Glory
What’s especially compelling is what this book does not include. You won’t find high-octane combat scenes, political diatribes, or self-righteous monologues. Instead, you’ll find a girl asking questions like: Why are people disappearing? Why can’t I wear that brown uniform? Why does the air feel different when the Americans arrive?
It is a memoir that respects the intelligence of its readers — leaving space for reflection rather than prescribing reaction.
For Whom the Bell Tolls… Softly
If you love memoirs that feel like a conversation with someone who’s lived many lives, this is for you.
-
Ideal readers include fans of Erik Larson, Martha Hall Kelly, and Laura Hillenbrand.
-
If you are a student of WWII, especially interested in civilian perspectives from Germany, you’ll find this work revelatory.
-
If you like fast plots and constant twists, this may not be your flavor. It is contemplative, not cinematic.
And for those who still believe that all Germans in the 1930s were the same — this book will give you pause.
Who It’s For (And Not For)
🟢 This book is for:
-
History lovers craving the untold angles of WWII.
-
Young readers (13+) seeking insight into moral complexity.
-
Families, schools, and book clubs looking for layered, reflective nonfiction.
🔴 Not for:
-
Readers seeking a thriller-style war story.
-
Those unwilling to sit with nuance or ambiguity.
-
Anyone expecting a sanitized or triumphalist narrative.
Final Thoughts
Ruth’s story reminds us that history doesn’t always come in black and white. Sometimes, it comes in sepia — the color of old photos, faded ink, and memory.
We often look back at history hoping to find clarity. What Ruth gives us instead is something braver: honesty. And sometimes, that’s what we need most.
Content Note
While the book is suitable for general readers, it does deal with:
-
World War II atrocities (indirect references)
-
Displacement, political oppression
-
Romantic complexities during wartime
These topics are presented in a sensitive and respectful manner and are appropriate for teen and adult audiences.
About the Author
Ruth Benario began writing this memoir in her mid-70s, drawing from the notes and diaries she had faithfully kept throughout her youth in Germany. The book focuses on her personal journey and the wide range of experiences she faced both before and during World War II. Told through the people who shaped her world, the memoir captures moments of both profound beauty and deep hardship. It also reflects Ruth’s emotional landscape—her experience of first love, the guidance and presence of her parents, feelings of anxiety and fear, and an intense will to survive through uncertain times. Ruth passed away in the United States in 2011 at the age of 88.
After her passing, her son, Peter Benario, took on the project. With the help of editor Carolyn Zalesne, he spent two years merging two versions of the manuscript, incorporating his father’s story, and completing the narrative with additional chapters to bring the full story to life.
- Listing ID: 36061
Discover more from The Chrysalis BREW Project
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.